Here is a full breakdown of why this happens and how to fix it.
If you have the FitGirl repack installed but also have Steam installed on your PC, you can leverage Steam's superior controller support without buying the game. fifa 19 fitgirl controller
This is the most reliable method for both PlayStation (DS4/DualSense) and generic USB controllers. Here is a full breakdown of why this
At its core, the problem stems from FIFA 19 ’s picky input recognition. Unlike native Steam titles that seamlessly integrate with PlayStation, Xbox, and Nintendo controllers via modern APIs, the cracked executable found in the FitGirl repack often lacks the latest Steam Input hooks. Consequently, a user connecting a DualShock 4 or a generic USB gamepad will find that the game either fails to register any input or maps buttons chaotically—triggers become start buttons, the right stick controls the camera, and the left stick moves through menus at hyperspeed. Xbox controllers fare slightly better due to native XInput, but even they can suffer from disconnection issues or trigger inversion. The repack’s untouched .exe, stripped of Origin’s background processes, loses the driver-level handshake that official version users take for granted. At its core, the problem stems from FIFA
If you are trying to play the FitGirl repack of FIFA 19 and your DualShock (PS4), Xbox, or generic controller is not working, you are not alone. This is a known technical conflict between the game's DRM bypass mechanisms and standard controller drivers.