Payton Preslee, a 22-year-old woman, was accused of being involved in the death of her boyfriend, 23-year-old Alexee Trevizo. The incident occurred in August 2022, in Hot Springs, Arkansas. According to reports, Preslee had called 911 and claimed that her boyfriend had died after falling down a flight of stairs. However, investigators soon discovered that the circumstances surrounding his death were suspicious.
| Issue | Statutory Provision | Court Interpretation | |-------|---------------------|----------------------| | | Tex. Code Crim. Art. 19.02(a)(1) – “Any person who commits or attempts to commit an act of violence that is intended to cause the death of an individual” | Jury found pre‑meditation based on the planning evidenced by the truck’s positioning and the subsequent concealment of the body. | | Aggravated Kidnapping | Art. 20.02(b)(1) – “Kidnapping of a person under 18 years of age” | Conviction hinged on the victim being restrained in the vehicle for over an hour. | | Dying Declaration Exception | Art. 38.03 – “A statement made by a declarant while believing death is imminent is admissible as an exception to the hearsay rule.” | The 911 call was admitted; the court held that Payton’s repeated pleas (“Help me, I’m being hurt”) satisfied the “belief of imminent death” requirement. | | Cell‑Site Analysis | Tex. Code Crim. Art. 42.11 (adopted by HB 4265, 2024) – Allows law‑enforcement to compel telecoms to provide historical location data for criminal investigations. | The appellate court affirmed the admissibility of the data, noting compliance with the statutory notice and minimization protocols. | | DNA Evidence Handling | Texas DNA Lab Act (Tex. Health & Safety Code § 141.002) – Governs collection, preservation, and analysis. | No violation found; chain‑of‑custody documentation was robust. | payton preslee case
This one will be published shortly.