Here's a brief summary of the controversy:
Soapgate.org and its associated links operate in a gray area of internet law. While the directory itself may only provide links, the destination sites frequently host copyrighted material without authorization. Consequently, the list of active domains on Soapgate is in a constant state of flux as it navigates the ongoing battle between free-access advocates and digital rights management (DRM) enforcers. soapgate.org
If you're looking for more detailed information on Soapgate, I suggest visiting the Soapgate.org website directly, as they likely have the most up-to-date and in-depth information on the topic. Here's a brief summary of the controversy: Soapgate